Can the procedural indemnity amount be challenged on appeal?
Detailed explanation of the procedural indemnity (PI) in Belgium: Article 1022 Judicial Code, Royal Decree, calculation methods, indexation, and current amounts.
Can the procedural indemnity amount be challenged on appeal?
Yes, but only as part of an appeal against the judgment as a whole — not as a standalone appeal.
If the judge deviated from the base amount — awarding either the minimum or the maximum — that decision can in principle be challenged through an ordinary appeal (hoger beroep / appel) or, in limited circumstances, a cassation appeal. The procedural indemnity forms part of the judgment as a whole and cannot usually be appealed in isolation.
In practice, a party wishing to challenge the amount of the procedural indemnity must include that ground in a broader appeal against the judgment. The appellate court will then review whether the first-instance judge correctly applied the four statutory criteria: the financial situation of the losing party, the complexity of the case, contractually agreed attorney fees, and the manifestly unreasonable character of the situation.
Note that in appeal proceedings, a new procedural indemnity is calculated separately for the appellate stage, based on the amount still in dispute on appeal.
Found an error or have a suggestion?
This information is maintained with care, but legislation changes. Have you noticed an inaccuracy or have a suggestion to improve this page? Let me know via pieterjan@scheir.eu.